Generalist platform or specialised industry solution: Which Chatbot is right for your property?


More accommodation providers than ever are adopting chatbots to boost revenues, and enhance the customer experience. Chatbots are powered by Artificial Intelligence (AI) and integrate with your hotel’s digital channels to handle guest queries, while cutting down on overheads. Sounds great, right? But how to choose the right chatbot solution for your property?


With a wide range of conversational AI solutions available, the decision to adopt a generalist or a specialised industry solution requires careful consideration. In an industry where sales, reception, and house keeping teams answer 100's of repetitive questions daily, opportunities for automation are enormous. However, at the same time, we must be mindful to not compromise the personal touch guests expect and demand.


The diverse conversational AI platforms market is comprised of many vendors worldwide. As a result, hoteliers looking to implement AI chatbot and Live Chat technology often struggle with vendor selection.


According to the Gartner report Making Sense of the Chatbot and Conversational AI Platform Market, choosing a horizontal vendor to solve a use case where a specialized vendor would have solved it quicker and faster needs to be a conscious decision. This needs to be viewed against flexibility and suitability for multiple use cases as well:

  • Horizontal solutions maximize flexibility. They do not target a specific use case, but seek to be useful as a foundation to any use case. Sometimes horizontal solution providers will have vertical or domain specialised solutions they can put on top of a horizontal one — trying to leverage the best of two worlds. A horizontal solution provides maximum flexibility and the most control, which has to be compared to the time-to-market advantage that a more specialised solution can give.

  • Vertical/domain specialised solutions come to the market with a set of accelerators or libraries that makes for a better fit for a particular industry, domain or use case. There can be significant savings in cost and effort if the specialisation is a good fit — but it can also be a path to multiple vendors in “chatbot soup.”

  • Task specialised is a vendor that specialises in one particular and highly specialised task, for example; booking meetings or rescheduling tickets. If the vendor can bring enough sophistication and automation to a common task, there might be no way an enterprise can replicate it using a horizontal or even vertical/domain specialised solution. Although, a task specific bot will lack flexibility to do new tasks at the same level of sophistication.


Therefore, the first few questions you need to ask yourself are:

  1. Do you have IT teams to implement and maintain the Horizontal solution?

  2. Do you have internal skills and manpower to manage the Natural Language Processing (NLP) pipeline i.e. creating intents, utterances, responses, and continuously training the NLP to improve the intent predictions?

  3. What is your time-to-market and investment limits you are willing to commit for?

  4. Do you know your integration requirements to your existing systems, such as Property Management System (PMS), Booking Engine, and CRM's

  5. The number and types of channels. For instance; developing a text only chatbot is often less complex than developing a chatbot that includes images, or that must also support channels like Facebook Messenger, Google Messaging, WhatsApp, and WeChat.

  6. Are you a multi property group or a standalone property? For a multi property group you need a solution that can support different responses based on the property selected.

  7. What is your property type? A resort, hotel, hostel, or a holiday park will have different questions customers will ask.

  8. The number of languages and language variant requirements can influence the sophistication of the solution required.

  9. How can you use the insights from the conversational data to understand guest requirements and unique needs?

  10. What are the other features you need from the solution e.g. Live Chat, Ticketing, Email, and Help Center?


Some of the horizontal/generalised solutions in the market

It’s a highly diverse market with vendors of varying capabilities, language support and strategies. According to Gartner, due to the wide variety of use cases, levels of sophistication, language and geographical support (and strategies of vendors) vendor selection is all about best fit. However, it is not currently possible to narrow down the market to a few vendors that will be a good choice for the majority of enterprises.


We've compiled a list of horizontal/generalised solutions that we've come across in the last 2 years.

Microsoft Bot Framework

Google Dialog Flow

Amazon Lex

Zendesk

Intercom

Drift

Tidio

Landbot

Ada

Freshchat

Outgrow


Book Me Bob is a vertical/domain specialised AI chatbot trained by hoteliers for hoteliers

Book Me Bob increases direct bookings, improves productivity, reduces costs and enhances the guest experience.

Things to consider

What to expect with a horizontal/ generalised solution

What to expect with Book Me Bob vertical/domain specialised solution

IT team involvement

Months of evaluation, requirements mapping and implementation effort

< 1 day with ready to use solution for hoteliers

NLP Skillset

Requires NLP competence in order to set up and maintain the intents, utterances and dialogues

Pre-trained to understand over 125,000 questions that a customer will ask a property

Time-to-market

Months

1 week

Investment

High setup and ongoing investment due to need for constant monitoring, tweaking and evolution

No to minimal setup fee, low monthly subscription fee

Integrations

Integrates with a number of everyday solutions like Shopify, Wordpress, and Hubspot

Integrates to most popular PMS and Booking Engines

Supported channels

  • Website

  • Facebook Messenger

  • Google Messaging

  • WeChat

  • WhatsApp

  • Website

  • Facebook Messenger

  • Google Messaging

  • WeChat

  • WhatsApp (Coming soon)

Property types

Custom setup required based on the property type

Ready to use NLP, purpose build for the unique needs of the following property types:

  • Resorts

  • Hotels

  • Hostels

  • Holiday parks

  • Holiday homes

Group properties

Usually support concept of a single business owner with multiple business units

Support group and standalone properties

Languages

Usually support available for multiple languages

Support for 20+ languages, with auto detection capabilities

Insights

Mostly, insights available for usage patterns and agent productivity

Book Me Bob gathers and processes important insights and data that can be used for future marketing and promotional opportunities.

Live Chat by agents

Supported by most platforms

Enabling customer initiated Live Chat is easy and in property's full control. You can choose how and when you want to make the option available (based on staffing levels) to your customers.


Supports both customer or agent initiated Live Chat

Ticketing

Supported by most of the platforms

Tickets are usually cases that that need a followup action by the property. Book Me Bob offer specialised conversational flows that capture tickets for:

  • Group bookings

  • Conference enquiries

  • Long stay enquiries

  • Post check-out requests

  • Pre check-in requests

Email

Supported by most of the platforms

Coming soon

So, Generalist or Specialist?

Now you know how generalist chatbots stretch horizontally, as opposed to specialist chatbots that develop vertically.


The generalised chatbots are usually a platform with a variety of features and tools. You need the NLP know how and the commitment to implement and manage the chatbot. On the other hand specialised chatbots are quick to adopt but not great if you are looking to implement an enterprise wide chatbot strategy with multiple use cases and needs.


When it come to accommodation providers, we’ve found that your website visitors and guests have specific and recurring needs that are best addressed end-to-end by a specialised solution. They are quick to implement, provide immediacy, and superior customer experience to the customers while ensuring additional features like ticketing and Live Chat are supported.



For more information about this comparison, please contact

Andy Dharmani

Co-Founder & CTO

andy@bookmebob.com

www.bookmebob.com



#Chatbot #ArtificialIntelligence